The Prime Buyer's Report

The definitive guide to local shopping; methodically researched, updated daily.

Orlando Edition

Prime Buyers Guide   Auto Repair Shops

The Best Auto Repair Shops in Seminole County FL Are the Ones Verified As Safe To Hire

Auto repair shops in Seminole County FL bearing The Prime Buyer's Report TOP 10 symbol are those that have exceeded the minimum Florida regulatory standard. They are the car repair services proven by our independent research to have passed the TOP 10 requirements for value and honesty, carry liability insurance as protection for you the customer, and for whom our staff has called previous customers to verify high satisfaction with them for auto repair in Seminole County FL, including tune ups, diagnostics, routine scheduled maintenance, fleet service and more.


Updated December 26, 2016

 The TOP 10 Auto Repair Shops in Seminole County FL

Tibbitts Inc
(407) 677-7190
2981 Alafaya Trl
Oviedo, FL 32765

Areas Served: Seminole County,Oviedo Florida,Sanford FL,Altamonte Springs,Winter Springs FL,
Services: auto mechanics for all car repairs incl. foreign cars, domestic cars

Marty's Auto Works
(407) 339-5491
154 Mingo Trl
Longwood, FL 32750

Areas Served: Seminole County,Wekiwa Springs,Sanford Florida,Altamonte Springs,Oviedo Florida
Services: engine repair, fuel pumps, auto diagnostics, all other car repairs

Cassleberry Auto Service
(407) 834-1065
1500 E Altamonte Dr
Fern Park, FL 32730

Areas Served: Oviedo Florida,Sanford Florida,Seminole County,Altamonte Springs,Casselberry FL
Services: all car repair services including domestic & foreign cars, engines, suspensions

CMC Automotive
(407) 302-4009
307 W 3rd St
Sanford, FL 32771

Areas Served: Casselberry FL,Seminole County,Wekiwa Springs,Sanford FL,Altamonte Springs FL
Services: local auto repair shop for engine repair, tune ups, diagnostics, foreign & domestic

Tuffy Auto Service Center
(407) 388-9800
5225 Red Bug Lake Rd
Winter Springs, FL 32708

Areas Served: Altamonte Springs,Seminole County,Oviedo FL,Sanford FL,Winter Springs FL,Forest City
Services: car mechanics for engine diagnostic repairs, tune-ups, scheduled maintenance

Automotive One Inc
(407) 695-7788
785 S US Highway 17 92
Longwood, FL 32750

Areas Served: Sanford Florida,Oviedo FL,Seminole County,Winter Springs FL,Altamonte Springs,FL
Services: car repair shop for scheduled car maintenance, major & minor repairs

The Best Auto Repair Shops in Seminole County FL Are the Ones Verified As Safe To Hire 

The state of Florida doesn't require any state license of auto repair shops in Seminole County FL merely a registration with the FDACS (Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services), so there's no state standard for competency in auto repair.

So there's no guarantee that any particular car repair shop in Seminole County FL is even competent, is doing business ethically, delivering value, or satisfying customers.

This makes it all the more significant that all services for auto repair in Seminole County FL which bear The Prime Buyer's Report-TOP 10 symbol have been cleared by our research staff as passing all requirements for Prime Buyer's Report-TOP 10 status such as survey phone calls to their previous customers to verify high satisfaction,  verified state registration, verified liability insurance for your protection, sufficient length of time in business, good complaint record, only employees legal to work in the U.S., and more.

The Florida Motor Vehicle Repair Act

If the car repair services will cost more than $100, the law requires the auto repair shop to give you the option of:

Requesting a written estimate;
Being notified by the auto repair shop if the car repair exceeds an amount you specify; or
Not requiring a written estimate at all.

You must sign and date one of the above options. Auto repair shops cannot force you to waive your right to an estimate.

When a written auto repair estimate is required, you must be given a copy.

The written estimate should clearly state if the price quoted is for new, used or rebuilt auto parts. 

The auto repair shop must get your approval before exceeding the car repair cost by more than $10 or 10%, whichever is greater.

You can cancel the car repair services if they exceed the estimate and the auto repair shop must reassemble the vehicle, unless it is unsafe to drive. The auto repair  shop may charge you for reassembly of the vehicle only if you were given notice of that charge on the estimate.

You are entitled by state law to get back any replaced parts if you requested them initially. However, the auto repair shop may charge a fee and, if the parts are under warranty agreement with the manufacturer or distributor, they may not be returned to you.

After auto repair services are completed, the written invoice detailing them must include:

Date and odometer reading.
Description of work.
Labor, parts and other merchandise costs.
Nature of parts (new, used, rebuilt, etc.)
Guarantee, if any.
Registration number from the certificate issued by FDACS identifying the auto repair shop.

Amount Over Written Estimate

If your auto repair bill exceeds the final estimate that you authorized by more than $10 or 10%, whichever is greater, and the auto repair shop refuses to give you your vehicle unless you pay, here is what you can do:

Obtain a copy of the bill from the auto repair shop and file a bond for the amount of the final car repair bill plus storage charges, if any, with the Clerk of the Circuit Court in the county where the auto repair shop is located.

The clerk will issue a certificate directing the auto repair shop to release your vehicle. A law enforcement officer will help deliver the certificate to the auto repair shop, if necessary.

The auto repair shop has 60 days to file a lawsuit to recover the bond as payment for the car repair. If the auto repair shop does not sue within 60 days, the clerk will return the bond money to you. The shop, however, can still file suit after release of the bond money.



Tips About Car Repair Services in Seminole County FL 

Ask for a written authorization to sign which authorizes the shop to inspect and diagnose the car problem, and which outlines all costs for this inspection, any additional costs that you will incur if you choose not to have them do the car repairs, and in what state the car will be returned to you (assembled or disassembled). You do this because some auto repair shops will agree to what you think is a free diagnosis, but then when the car has been taken apart, only then do they tell you about an exorbitant charge to have the car reassembled to working order.

Get the estimate put in writing and detailed, even if the auto repair shop has given it to you verbally in person or on the phone. A written estimate can avoid misunderstandings later, and having it written out in detail could remind you of something to ask, add, or remove that you would have overlooked. You are not troubling the shop by asking them to put it in writing. Any professional repair shop will be used to doing so.


Verify that the written estimate includes all charges, i.e. labor, towing, parts, storage, rental car, or any other charge.

If the work includes replacing parts, make sure the estimate specifies whether the parts are brand new or instead are refurbished, and whether they are OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) or not. OEM parts are those made by the company who supplies the parts to the auto maker and which your car came with.  Non-OEM parts, often referred to as aftermarket parts, are often cheaper but they will not last as long. That might be okay with you depending on your plans for the car but you deserve to make an informed decision and give your consent either way.


Don't have someone else like your boyfriend, child, or sibling also get involved with the shop during the process of getting an estimate. Dishonest repair shops will use that as an excuse to later say you owe for repairs that other person supposedly gave permission for.

Make sure the written authorization form details all charges, states that there are no other charges besides those outlined in the form, and states a date on which the work will be done and your car returned to you. Tell the auto repair shop to state in writing that you are to be given any old parts that were replaced, along with the box the new ones came in. That gives you more assurance that the new part you paid for really was installed. Some car repair shops have been caught defrauding customers by charging for parts that were never installed.

It will only make things worse for you.  If there's a disagreement with the shop which you can't resolve, don't refuse to pay the bill. They have the legal right to keep your car until you pay them and they can add daily storage charges than can run into the thousands. So pay the bill but put in writing that you don't agree with the charges and are paying under protest. Then pursue a complaint with the Florida State Attorney General's office and/or a civil suit like in small claims court. Don't pay with a check with the intention to cancel the check once you have your car back, since the shop can legally repossess your car as a result.



Questions to Ask Auto Repair Shops in Seminole County FL 

If possible, speak with the most senior mechanic there or the owner. Ask the following questions about their abilities, credentials, and experience. Write down their answers.

• How long has this auto repair shop been in business?

• Is there a fee to inspect and diagnose the problem?

• Can they give names and numbers of customers you can call as references? (All auto repair shops bearing the Prime Buyer's Report-TOP 10 symbol have already had their customer references verified by our research staff so you don't have to.)

• How do they charge? Is it a flat fee per type of repair, or based on the number of hours worked?

• Will the put the repair estimate in writing?

• How often do they service your exact car model and make?

• Do they have OE diagnostic scanners specific to your make and model? An OBDII scanner is a low-cost generic scanner that will not show all the possible trouble codes for your specific car. A make/model specific scanner, referred to as an OE scanner (Original Equipment), is specific to a certain make of car. It's more expensive for the shop to own, so not every shop will have one for your car.

• Will they provide a written authorization for you to sign before beginning repairs? Written documentation is their assessment of what work is required. In case they're wrong about the problem, you might be able to get a refund or the additional repair at no cost. Their verbal recommendation on what they think you should do does not provide the same protection for you.  

• Have they had other instances of this make and model needing the exact service you're asking about?

• Do they use OEM parts (original equipment manufacturer) or instead, lower quality aftermarket parts, or refurbished auto parts?  Those lower quality options are cheaper, but a good shop would only use them after first explaining it as an option and letting you decide on the risk versus the short term cost savings. The best car repair shops use OEM parts. Cheap shops will use low-quality substitute parts without telling you, which is how the shop appears to be cheaper but really isn't.

• Do they have liability insurance that will reimburse you in the event of damage to your car while it's on their property or as a result of repair mistakes? (All shops bearing the Prime Buyer's Report-TOP 10 symbol have already had their insurance verified by our research staff so you don't have to.)

• Will the repairs invalidate or affect your manufacturer's warranty in any way?

• Will they honor your car warranty?

• What kind of written guarantee do they give on their repair work?

• How long will it take to finish your car repairs?

• What action would the car mechanic take personally if this was his car?

When you've chosen the best car repair shop for your needs, make sure it is registered with the State of Florida and has any legally necessary license from Seminole County. (All shops bearing the Prime Buyer's Report-TOP 10 symbol have already had their state registration and county license verified by our research staff so you don't have to.)





Record or Write a Review

Consumers use the Prime Buyer's Report to avoid the scam, fraud, and businesses with low customer satisfaction.

Independent research conducted by Prime Buyer's Report editors includes phone call surveys with customers of local businesses, checks with state agencies on license and complaint history, verification that each business has insurance coverage to protect you as a customer, phone interviews of business owners, signed agreements that they use only legal workers, and more to determine the businesses that are safe to spend with.

See All The Research Steps

Auto Repair Shops in Seminole County serving Geneva, Midway, Longwood, Sanford, Heathrow, Forest City, Altamonte Springs, Wekiwa Springs, Chuluota, Lake Mary, Black Hammock, Casselberry, Springs, Winter Springs, Fern Park and Oviedo



Tips About Car Repair Services in Seminole County FL

Top Tips for getting auto repairs in Seminole County FL. more »



Questions to Ask Auto Repair Shops in Seminole County FL

more »



more »