The definitive guide to local shopping; methodically researched, updated daily.

November 14, 2019
A family shops for new mattresses at a local mattress store.

The Best Mattress Stores in Sarasota County FL Are the Ones Proven Safe To Buy From

Mattress stores in Sarasota County FL bearing The Prime Buyer's Report TOP 10 symbol are those mattress dealers proven by our independent research to have passed the TOP 10 requirements for value and honesty, and for whom our staff has called previous customers to verify high satisfaction with the value received for the sale of new mattresses in Sarasota County FL, including adjustable mattresses, latex mattresses, organic mattresses, pillow top mattresses and more.

 

The TOP 10 Mattress Stores in Sarasota County FL

Sleep Number By Select Comfort

  • Sleep Number By Select Comfort Profile
  • Sleep Number By Select Comfort Scorecard
  • Sleep Number By Select Comfort Reviews
  • Sleep Number By Select Comfort Photos
  • Sleep Number By Select Comfort Brands
  • Sleep Number By Select Comfort Articles
  • Sleep Number By Select Comfort Offers
(941) 924-1118
5077 Fruitville Rd # 101
Sarasota, FL 34232

Areas Served: North Port Florida, Sarasota FL, Sarasota County FL, South Venice…
Services: new mattress incl. innerspring mattress, organic mattress, orthopedia mattresses

Land of Sleep

  • Land of Sleep Profile
  • Land of Sleep Scorecard
  • Land of Sleep Reviews
  • Land of Sleep Photos
  • Land of Sleep Brands
  • Land of Sleep Articles
  • Land of Sleep Offers
(941) 921-4468
7626 S Tamiami Trl
Sarasota, FL 34231

Areas Served: Sarasota Florida, Sarasota County FL, Fruitville FL, Venice FL, North…
Services: mattress store for sales of solid foam mattresses, latex mattress,…

Mattress Direct Outlet Inc

  • Mattress Direct Outlet Inc Profile
  • Mattress Direct Outlet Inc Scorecard
  • Mattress Direct Outlet Inc Reviews
  • Mattress Direct Outlet Inc Photos
  • Mattress Direct Outlet Inc Brands
  • Mattress Direct Outlet Inc Articles
  • Mattress Direct Outlet Inc Offers
(941) 408-9792
1875 Tamiami Trl S
Venice, FL 34293

Areas Served: Gulf Gate Estates FL, Sarasota Springs FL, Venice FL, Sarasota…
Services: mattresses incl. california king size, crib mattress, toddler mattresses, futon…

Mattress Firm

  • Mattress Firm Profile
  • Mattress Firm Scorecard
  • Mattress Firm Reviews
  • Mattress Firm Photos
  • Mattress Firm Brands
  • Mattress Firm Articles
  • Mattress Firm Offers
(941) 423-5858
7000 Sumter Crossing Dr
North Port, FL 34287

Areas Served: North Port FL, Bee Ridge FL, Fruitville FL, Sarasota County…
Services: local mattress store for adjustable mattresses, boxsprings, mattress toppers

Mattress Store of Sarasota

  • Mattress Store of Sarasota Profile
  • Mattress Store of Sarasota Scorecard
  • Mattress Store of Sarasota Reviews
  • Mattress Store of Sarasota Photos
  • Mattress Store of Sarasota Brands
  • Mattress Store of Sarasota Articles
  • Mattress Store of Sarasota Offers
(941) 929-7378
6979 S Tamiami Trl
Sarasota, FL 34231

Areas Served: Sarasota County FL, Venice Florida, Sarasota FL, North Port FL,…
Services: mattresses incl crib mattresses, child mattresses, innerspring mattress delivery

Mattress Pros

  • Mattress Pros Profile
  • Mattress Pros Scorecard
  • Mattress Pros Reviews
  • Mattress Pros Photos
  • Mattress Pros Brands
  • Mattress Pros Articles
  • Mattress Pros Offers
(941) 475-4204
4275 S Access Rd
Englewood, FL 34224

Areas Served: Sarasota Florida, Sarasota County FL, Fruitville FL, Venice FL, North…
Services: boxspring & mattresses, delivery, warranties, most mattress brands

Mattress Xpress Sarasota

  • Mattress Xpress Sarasota Profile
  • Mattress Xpress Sarasota Scorecard
  • Mattress Xpress Sarasota Reviews
  • Mattress Xpress Sarasota Photos
  • Mattress Xpress Sarasota Brands
  • Mattress Xpress Sarasota Articles
  • Mattress Xpress Sarasota Offers
(941) 556-8647
3908 S Tamiami Trl
Sarasota, FL 34231

Areas Served: Sarasota County, North Port FL, Sarasota FL, Venice FL, Sarasota…
Services: local mattress sales, adjustable mattresses, folding mattresses, latex mattresses

Sleep King

  • Sleep King Profile
  • Sleep King Scorecard
  • Sleep King Reviews
  • Sleep King Photos
  • Sleep King Brands
  • Sleep King Articles
  • Sleep King Offers
(941) 925-8949
1901 Hansen St
Sarasota, FL 34231

Areas Served: Sarasota Springs FL, Sarasota County FL, Venice FL, North Port…
Services: orthopedic mattresses, pillow top mattress, gel mattress, organic mattress

Mattress Factory Outlet LLC

  • Mattress Factory Outlet LLC Profile
  • Mattress Factory Outlet LLC Scorecard
  • Mattress Factory Outlet LLC Reviews
  • Mattress Factory Outlet LLC Photos
  • Mattress Factory Outlet LLC Brands
  • Mattress Factory Outlet LLC Articles
  • Mattress Factory Outlet LLC Offers
(941) 896-3983
6915 15th St E # 209
Sarasota, FL 34243

Areas Served: Sarasota County, South Venice FL, Sarasota FL, Venice FL, Sarasota…
Services: memory foam mattresses, innerspring mattresses, pillow top mattress

The Best Mattress Stores in Sarasota County FL Are the Ones Proven Safe To Buy From

The state of Florida does not require mattress stores in Sarasota County FL to qualify for a state license for mattress sales, so there is no state standard for competency among mattress dealers to guarantee that any particular store for mattresses in Sarasota County FL is doing business honestly, giving value, or satisfying their customers.

This makes it all the more significant that all mattress stores in Sarasota County FL that bear The Prime Buyer's Report-TOP 10 symbol have been cleared by our research staff as passing all the requirements for Prime Buyer's Report-TOP 10 status such as survey phone calls to previous customers to verify high satisfaction for mattress sales, best business practices, sufficient length of time in business, good complaint record, and more.

What To Look For When Buying A Mattress

The biggest considerations are to how well the mattress supports you and keeps you in normal alignment so you don't wake with back pain, and comfort, so that you're not forced to move around all night resulting in a bad night's sleep.   With support, a too firm mattress will not yield enough to your body's curves, forcing your spine out of its natural alignment. A too soft mattress can create the same result the same way lying in a hammock does.  With comfort, a too firm mattress or one badly constructed can cause pressure points on places of your body, cutting off circulation.

Additional considerations include:

Motion transfer (for those sleeping with a partner)
To prevent being woken when a sleeping partner moves, you want a mattress without much motion transfer. That can be accomplished in different ways. For innerspring mattresses, coil springs that are not connected to each other and are individually wrapped will have less motion transfer than less expensive coils that are interlinked. Memory foam mattress or latex mattresses can have less motion transfer than innerspring mattresses.

Temperature neutrality
A mattress that gets too warm or stays too cold can prevent you from sleeping well. Preventing the mattress from being too much warmer or colder than your body can be achieved by construction that uses ventilation, and/or advanced foams. Cheap memory foam mattresses have the biggest risk of getting too warm.

Edge support
Many mattress brands cut their manufacturing costs by skimping on the inside materials around the edges of mattress on the idea that people only spend their time near the center. But if you have a habit of sleeping near the edge, or sitting on the edge frequently, then not only would poor edge support be uncomfortable but it can also cause that part of the mattress to break down and sag relatively soon.

Types of Mattresses in Sarasota County FL

Innerspring Mattresses
The most common type of mattress in Sarasota County FL, these contain coils of steel springs. Coil count refers to exactly how many coils are inside the mattress, with those at 420 coils or below being most suitable for sporadic use such as in a guest bedroom.  A higher coil count will provide more comfort and is more suitable for every day use, however the number of coils isn't always the only factor since another is how thick the steel of each coil is, also how many turns each coil has. So it's possible for a 800 coil mattress to have thicker coil steel and/more coil turns than a 900 coil mattress and be more comfortable than the higher coil count mattress.  Common brands of mattresses in Sarasota County FL of this type include Stearns & Foster, Simmons Beauty Rest, Serta, and Sealy mattresses. Others that some local mattress stores sell include Englander and Corsicana.

Memory Foam Mattresses
Memory foam is a slow-response type of foam that takes longer to return to its normal position when you remove the weight from it.  Tempurpedic is a well known brand of this mattress type. Memory foam shouldn't be confused with the regular foam, often called poly foam, that can be found in the top layers of an innerspring mattress, the cheapest of which can break down (lose its rebounding property) after repeated use.

Latex Mattresses
Latex mattress come in two kinds of latex, Dunlop latex or Talalay latex (or a combination of both). Both types of latex are made from rubber sap. Latex mattresses can be pricey but can also last decades and are appreciated for being anti-bacterial and anti-dust mite since mites do not thrive in natural latex.

Some mattresses are latex hybrids, having only a top layer of the most expensive material, the latex, over a memory foam or innerspring mattress, and so can be less costly (and lighter) than a 100% latex mattress.

Latex toppers can also be purchased separately, a 1", 2" or some other thickness of latex to place on top of an existing mattress.

Spring Air Mattresses
Air mattresses use chambers inflated with air instead of spring coils, and offer the ability to make an adjustible bed, so that the user can adjust one side to be firmer or softer than the other side in order to satisfy two sleeping partners independently. The Sleep Number bed by Select Comfort is a well known brand in this category.

How to Buy New Mattresses in Sarasota County FL

Try The Mattress Before Buying

Try lying on the mattress in different positions, not just on your back, and feel free to lie on the mattress for as long as 10 to 15 minutes to get a better idea of the support, possible pressure points, and temperature neutrality of the new mattress.

If you're buying the mattress online without the ability to try it first, make sure you understand the online mattress retailer's return policy (if any). Online mattress sales that offer an extended trial period can cut down on the liklihood of disappointment, but make sure you are comfortable with what your obligation might be in order to get the matteress returned.

Price Match Guarantee?

Does the mattress store guarantee to match a lower price of the same mattress being sold at another local mattress store in Sarasota County FL, or being sold online?

Is There A Sale Coming Up?

Will the store sell the new mattress you want at a lower price sometime in the near future as part of a scheduled sale or promotion?

Reconsider The Need For The Platform (Box Spring)

The platform that goes underneath the mattress, which some people mistakenly call a box spring, usually doesn't have springs in it anymore. These days, it is typically just a simple wood frame, with one box or platform being pretty much the same as any other, except for being in a fabric that matches the new mattress when purchased as a set. Considering that the box or platform is rarely visible, especially once bed covers are on, you might save by reusing your existing box or platform and buying only a new mattress.

Price Is Not The Only Factor

If you're inclined to do price comparisons between mattress stores in Sarasota County FL, make sure you've tallied all the costs, such as the mattress delivery fee and if the mattress store will charge you to remove your old mattress or not.   

Next, bear in mind that when comparing price between different models of new mattresses, that the most expensive is not necessarily the best. Like with other retail goods, some mattresses have a premium price only because the maker knows some consumers like to buy high end, believing it guarantees more value. Next, price comparisons between different models, even among the same maker can be difficult because many times a mattress is made specific to that retailer, such as for ones sold in department stores, and there might not be an exact match of that mattress in terms of its actual material and construction.

Lastly, weigh any price difference against possible differences in return policy (and restocking fee), or in the warranty. Saving a couple of hundred dollars is no bargain if you end up unhappy with a mattress that is uncomfortable and compromises your sleep and your health over months and years.