The definitive guide to local shopping; methodically researched, updated daily.

October 17, 2018

The Best Auto Repair Shops in Suffolk County NY Are the Ones Proven Safe To Hire

Auto repair shops in Suffolk County NY bearing The Prime Buyer's Report TOP 10 symbol are those car repair services proven by our independent research to have passed the TOP 10 requirements for value and honesty, carry liability insurance as protection for you the customer, and for whom our staff has called previous customers to verify high satisfaction with them for auto repair in Suffolk County NY, including diagnostics, tune ups, fleet service, routine scheduled maintenance, and more.

 
 

The TOP 10 Auto Repair Shops in Suffolk County NY

Venero Motors Corp

(631) 472-0589
405 Lakeview Ave
Bayport, NY 11705

Areas Served: Suffolk County, Holtsville NY, Brentwood NY, Copiague NY, Shirley NY,…
Services: car repairs incl. domestic cars, import cars, engine repair, fuel…

Kudrick’s Auto Repair Ltd

(631) 737-4387
430 Union Ave
Holbrook, NY 11741

Areas Served: Selden NY, Medford NY, Commack NY, West Babylon NY, Mastic…
Services: all auto repairs incl. suspension, shocks, struts, fuel injection, engine…

East Coast Automotive

(631) 750-0738
123 Knickerbocker Ave
Bohemia, NY 11716

Areas Served: Suffolk County NY, West Babylon NY, Brentwood NY, Commack NY,…
Services: auto repair shop for car repair, engine repair, scheduled maintenance

Motorworks Engine Center

(631) 608-4380
111 Sunrise Hwy
Amityville, NY 11701

Areas Served: Brentwood NY, Suffolk County NY, Lindenhurst NY, Deer Park NY,…
Services: all auto repairs, foreign & domestic car repairs, engine repairs,…

Smith Brothers Auto Repair Inc

(631) 981-4510
75 Hawkins Ave
Ronkonkoma, NY 11779

Areas Served: West Babylon NY, Suffolk County New York, West Islip NY,…
Services: car repair shops, auto mechanics for all car repairs, tune-ups,…

Faber Brothers Automotive Repair

(631) 665-5550
279 Orinoco Dr
Brightwaters, NY 11718

Areas Served: Brentwood NY, Ronkonkoma NY, East Patchogue NY, Deer Park NY,…
Services: local auto repair shop for engine repair, tune ups, diagnostics,…

N&J Auto Tec

(631) 385-8310
115 W 11th St
Huntington Station, NY 11746

Areas Served: Brentwood NY, Coram NY, Lake Ronkonkoma NY, Bay Shore NY,…
Services: auto repairs including alignment, repair diagnostics, engine repair, tune-ups

The Best Auto Repair Shops in Suffolk County NY Are the Ones Proven Safe To Hire

The state of New York does not require auto repair shops in Suffolk County NY to qualify for a state license, so there is no state standard for competency among auto repair services. Likewise, New York doesn't require  that services for car repair in Suffolk County NY first show the state proof of liability insurance to reimburse you in the event of any damages that might occur during servicing.

So there is no guarantee that any particular auto repair shop in Suffolk County NY is even competent, is doing business ethically, delivering value, or satisfying customers.

This makes it all the more significant that all services for auto repair in Suffolk County NY that bear The Prime Buyer's Report-TOP 10 symbol have been cleared by our research staff as passing all the requirements for Prime Buyer's Report-TOP 10 status such as survey phone calls to previous customers to verify high satisfaction with their auto repair services, good complaint record, verified liability insurance, sufficient length of time in business, only employees legal to work in the U.S., and more.

New Jersey has a law called the Auto Repairs Deceptive Practices Regulations which declares certain practices or omissions as illegal if committed by auto repair shops in Suffolk County NY as follows:

• Make any written or oral statements that are misleading and deceptive which the automotive repair dealer knows to be untrue or misleading.

• Start work without first having received a signed written authorization from the customer which clearly states the nature of the car repair and the odometer reading of the vehicle, or if during other than normal working hours, verbal authorization from the customer to proceed with the auto repair.

• Start work without first giving the customer a written estimate. The total price must be stated either as "price not to exceed" a certain amount or as an exact figure broken down into parts and labor.

• Fail to provide the customer with a copy of any receipt or documents signed by the customer, at the time they signed them.

• Make false promises which are likely to influence, persuade, or induce the customer to authorize the auto repair, service, or maintenance of the car.

• Charge the customer for work done or for parts supplied which are in excess of the estimate given, without the prior oral or written consent of the consumer.

• Fail to return parts to the customer at the time the repair is completed provided that the customer, before the work was started, requested the return of parts.

• Fail to record on an invoice all car repair services performed by the auto repair shop for a customer. The invoice should clearly and separately itemize the charges for parts and labor and also state whether any new, rebuilt, or used parts were supplied in the car repair.

• Fail to provide a copy to the customer of any guarantee that clearly discloses all of its terms.

• Fail to post in a conspicuous place a sign informing the customer that the auto repair shop must provide a written estimate, copies of all receipts, detailed invoices, a copy of any guarantees that are offered, and that the customer has the right to the return of any replaced parts.

How to Communicate with Auto Repair Shops in Suffolk County NY

Before you take your car to the auto repair shop, pay attention to your car's problem. Be specific in describing your car's symptoms and tell the car repair shop about any past repairs for similar trouble.

Although you may not fully understand the technical terms, carefully listen to the mechanic's diagnosis.

Don't be afraid to ask questions if you don't understand something.

Get a cost estimate in writing and instruct the auto repair shop to call for authorization before doing any car repair services not listed on the original repair order.

If you believe the car repair shop has recommended unnecessary work or you are dissatisfied with the estimate, get a second opinion. This is an especially good idea when major auto repair is needed.

If the auto repair shop recommends replacing certain parts, ask for the old parts. You may receive credit on some parts if the mechanic wants to keep them. It's a particularly good idea to keep the old parts if you are concerned that unnecessary work is being done. If you want the old parts returned, be sure that requirement is written on the repair order before  the work begins.

Many disputes don't arise until consumers pick up their cars and see the service bills. How to avoid disputes:

• Specifically list the labor, parts, and services performed. Be sure the repairs listed on the repair order cover all the problems you described.

• If the auto repair shop offers a guarantee on their work, get all the warranty information in writing on the repair order or bill.

• If you do have a problem, such as the bill greatly exceeding the estimate or the auto repairs being made improperly, go back to the original mechanic. Often, a dispute can be settled quickly and calmly.

• If the business refuses to correct the problem or answer your questions about the bill, legal action may be appropriate. Your can contact the Attorney General's Office.

Auto Repair Shops in Suffolk County NY Perform Numerous Services

Auto repair shops do everything from routine maintenance including the scheduled maintenance recommended by the manufacturer (30K/60K/90K), diagnostics including the use of sophisticated modern computers, car winterization, major engine overhauls, suspension work and fleet service for local businesses like taxi companies, rental companies, trucking companies, etc. But some shops are better than others. Some have more investment in the latest diagnostic equipment, have more bays and lifts to reduce waiting time and increase turn around time, higher education and qualification levels of their mechanics.  Some have more comprehensive experience and technical capability allowing them to perform all aspects in-house while others may have to send your car out to a specialist for certain aspects of the work.

If your car has started exhibiting symptoms like a lit check engine light, engine stumbling, trouble idling, lack of power, difficulty starting, or a number of related issues, you may need a mechanic who can perform a full auto diagnostic scan to find the exact problem. Most auto repair shops should be able to perform general auto repairs including tune ups, belt replacements, car radiator service and engine hose replacement. The best car repair services will also be able to do more complicated auto repairs like fuel injection and carburetor service, ignition and battery checks, suspension sales and service, performance add-ons and aftermarket  accessory installations, engine overhauls, valve jobs, head gasket replacement, and even full engine replacements.

Check Engine Light / Free Check Engine Light Diagnosis
A trip to the mechanic is often preceded by a check engine light warning.  A check engine light can be due to something as simple as a loose gas cap or the need to add oil. But it can also be an indication of a more serious problem that will get worse the longer it goes unattended.  Various national chains have advertised a free check engine light diagnosis in Suffolk County NY. Bear in mind that free check engine diagnosis probably consists of just a few moments to connect a scanner to your vehicle and get the read out of the trouble codes.   The problem with this is that trouble codes are just a starting clue to a technician as to what might be wrong.  Some trouble codes will indicate a failed sensor that hasn't really failed. One of the most common trouble codes indicates a misfire and the easiest suggestion by a shop is start with a tune-up and see if that fixes the problem. Then when it doesn't you've paid for a tune-up you didn't need, and wasted time and money.  Another code indicates that a new catalytic converter is needed at $2,000 but might really be just the need for an exhaust gasket or O2 sensor.  That's why good, honest mechanics will follow up the engine diagnostic and trouble codes by a test drive and a closer look at the engine.

Another issue is the scanner used for that free check engine light diagnostic. Likely it is done with the OBDII scanner, a low cost generic scanner that can cost as little as $35 but it will not display all the information that the appropriate scanner for your make and model would.  A model-specific OE scanner can cost as much as $5,000 so usually only an auto repair shop that regularly services your make and model is likely to use it.  Before undertaking that free check engine light diagnosis, ask if the generic OBDII scanner will be used or one specific to your vehicle and if you will get written documentation rather than a recommendation only. Often, a mere verbal recommendation is a sign they're just guessing at what's wrong, where getting written documentation means they've done what's necessary to know for sure, such as a test drive or using a scanner specific to your car. The documentation prior to undertaking repair work gives you potential recourse for a refund for that work if the solution proscribed in writing turns out to be wrong, which is usually not the case if you spend for services based on a verbal recommendation.

Electric car repair shops in Suffolk County NY

Battery electric cars require less maintenance than gas or diesel cars since there are no oil changes, spark plug changes, muffler repairs needed and the engine has fewer moving parts, but there is still a need for electric car repair services. For example the Tesla has a differential gear box with transmission fluid inside that still needs scheduled changing. And electric cars still have air conditioning systems to be recharged, coolant to be replaced, and brake replacement or repairs that will be needed.

EVs (electric vehicles) can also have issues with the batteries, most certainly the eventual need to replace the entire battery pack since nickel-metal-hydride and lithium-ion batteries have a limited lifespan and will eventually become less efficient.

Regularly scheduled maintenance for electric cars is required.

Some auto repair shops in Suffolk County NY might encourage you to come in for electric car repairs simply because they're eager to take a crack at your car and gain some learning experience, but you don't want your electric car to be their guinea pig. So when choosing an electric car repair shop in Suffolk County NY make sure they have manufacturer training on electric vehicles and/or that they have serviced or repaired a lot electric cars before yours.

The following tips will also help you to choose and communicate with a local car repair service.With so many different types of cars, trucks and SUVs, auto repair shops can fill many different niches, from BMW repair only to the most affordable for that old get-around car. There are a few basic steps you can take when looking for a place you can be confident about.

Don't wait until you have a car repair emergency. Shop around for good car repair shops and auto mechanics in Suffolk County NY before you really need them. You'll likely make a better decision when you're not rushed by having to deal immediately with a breakdown or major car repairs, so it pays to do some research ahead of time. Choosing a good auto repair shop with honest mechanics now for regular maintenance is also the best way to avoid major car repairs by keeping your vehicle in top running condition.

Plan ahead. If you can, arrange for a ride before you take your car or truck in for repairs. This way, you won't need to pick a shop just because it's closer to home.

Do a test run with a shop. It's a good idea to work with a car repair shop on small repairs before trusting their mechanics to handle a major car repair. Call ahead and schedule a basic service such as a tune-up. Usually, customers with appointments have priority over walk-ins. This will give you a chance to see how they operate and experience their customer service. Are they busy? Do they get your work done quickly? Are the other customer vehicles in their parking lot the same make or same value as your car or truck? Note how clean and organized the office and shop are. Pay special attention to the attitude of the car mechanics and the staff.

Understand the basics. Mechanics should be able to answer your questions and make time to discuss your concerns. The best auto repair shops in Suffolk County have professional staff. Make sure they answer your questions and give you the information you need to make a good decision. Some shops specialize in certain makes of car or in certain repairs. It is important to know an auto repair shop is able to work on your car and handle your particular car repairs.

Pricing. If your vehicle is still under warranty, make sure they will honor the warranty. Find out how they  price auto repairs-is there a flat rate for each type of repair job or are prices based on parts and labor? Get in writing a detailed estimate and contract before going ahead with any car repairs. But remember-price shouldn't be the only factor. Cheap rates can mean lower standards, cheap knock-off parts or less-experienced mechanics. Look for shops with both fair pricing, experienced repair technicians, and quality parts.

Warranties & Guarantees. Find out if the car repair shop is backed by a national warranty plan, especially if you travel out of the local area frequently in your car. Such national warranty plans typically cover parts and labor on your vehicle anywhere in the country for 12 months or 12,000 miles.

Get it in writing. Policies such as guarantees, labor rates, accepted methods of payment and business hours will be posted in good auto repair shops. You should also be able to get in writing quotes for specific services, detailed estimates and exact warranty coverage for your car's repairs. Keep all paperwork the shop gives you. Even though they keep customer files, it is a good idea to keep your own records.

Discuss any problems. If you are unhappy with the service, give them a chance to make it right. Communication is important, so talk with the owner. The management at good shops will listen to your concerns and work to fix the problem. They have a personal interest in making you happy and keeping your business. Honest auto repair shops in Suffolk County NY will take responsibility for their work.

Some Auto Repair Shops in Suffolk County NY Are Much Better Than Others
The Prime Buyer's Report lists these auto repair shops in Suffolk County NY: . Others car repair shops in Suffolk County NY that might still be in business include: .

Questions to Ask Auto Repair Shops in Suffolk County NY


If possible, speak with the most senior auto mechanic there or the owner of the auto repair shop. Ask these questions about their experience, abilities, and credentials and write down their answers:

• How long have they been in business? (All auto repair shops in Suffolk County NY bearing the Prime Buyer's Report-TOP 10 symbol have already had sufficient time in business verified by our research staff so you don't have to.)

• Do they charge a fee to inspect and diagnose your car repair problem?

• Can they give names and numbers of previous customers you can call as references? (All car repair shops in Suffolk County NY bearing the Prime Buyer's Report-TOP 10 symbol have already had their customer references called by our research staff so you don't have to.)

• How do they determine cost? Do they charge a flat fee or base the price on hours worked?

• Will the put the initial estimate in writing?

• How often do they repair your exact car make and model?

• Do they have OE diagnostic equipment specific to your make and model? An OBDII scanner is a generic low-cost scanner that will not return all the possible trouble codes. A make/model specific scanner, also referred to as an OE scanner (Original Equipment), is made specifically for a certain make of car and is costlier form them to buy, so not every shop has it.

• Will they give you a written authorization for you to sign before undertaking repairs? Written documentation is their assessment of what work is required. In case they're wrong about the problem, you might be able to get a refund or the additional repair at no cost. Their verbal recommendation on what they think you should do does not provide the same protection for you. Get it in writing.

• Have they had other instances of this make and model needing the exact service you're asking about?

• Do they use OEM parts (original equipment manufacturer) or instead, lower quality aftermarket parts, or used auto parts?  Those lower quality options might be cheaper, but a good shop would only use them after first explaining it as an option and letting you weigh the risk versus the short term cost savings. The best auto repair shops use OEM parts. Some cheap shops will use the low-quality substitutes without telling you, which is how the shop appears cheaper when it really isn't.

• Do they have liability insurance to reimburse you in the event of damage to your car while it's in their care or as a result of the repair work? (All auto repair shops in Suffolk County NY bearing the Prime Buyer's Report-TOP 10 symbol have already had proof of insurance verified by our research staff so you don't have to.)

• Will the work invalidate or affect your manufacturer's warranty in any way?

• Will they honor your car warranty?

• What kind of written guarantee do they give on their car repairs?

• How long should it take to complete your car repairs?

• What action would the auto mechanic take personally if this was his car?

When you've chosen the best car repair service in Suffolk County NY for your needs, make sure they have a good complaint record. (All auto repair shops in Suffolk County NY bearing the Prime Buyer's Report-TOP 10 symbol have already had a good complaint status verified by our research staff so you don't have to.)

Research on Car Repair in Suffolk County NY

Common Auto Repair Terms and Definitions

Active suspensions / active suspension systems - Also called a computer-controlled suspension system. A computerized vehicle system able to control body roll, body pitch, brake dive, acceleration squat and ride height. Suspension systems are controlled by double-acting hydraulic cylinders or solenoids (actuators) mounted at each wheel. Actuators support the vehicle's weight, instead of conventional springs or air springs.

Axle / Front axle / Rear axle - A cross member supporting a vehicle on which one or more wheels are mounted. Can also refer to a pair of wheels on a vehicle.

British Car Repair Shops - Are those that specialize in British car repairs for popular models such as Jaguar and Mini Cooper repair services, and also luxury british cars with Bentley and Rolls Royce repair services. Sporty models like like MG, MGB, and the Triumph are no longer in production but British car repair specialists in Suffolk County NY are more familiar with car repairs on these British car models than average car repair shops. The same is true for Austin Healey and Aston Martin repairs in Suffolk County NY.

Check Engine Light - A warning light, usually located on the instrument cluster. When lit, it indicates possible engine problems or system problems that require engine repair or other auto repair services.

Cylinder - The round holes inside an engine block that make space for the pistons.

Cylinder Block - The basic framework of an engine. All other parts and assemblies are installed or attached to the cylinder block.

Cylinder Head - The part of the engine that covers cylinders and pistons.

Detroit Diesel Two-Stroke Engines - A type of engine where air enters the cylinder through cylinder liner ports

Diesel Engine - A compression-ignition engine that runs on diesel fuel. Many popular German auto brands are known for their diesel engines, such as Mercedes Benz and BMW (Bavarian Motor Works).  The popularity of diesel engines for German cars and European cars generally has several reasons. A diesel engine is cheaper to run than a gasoline engine, since diesel fuel is less expensive. Next, diesel fuel has 20% more energy per gallon than gas, and almost double that of ethanol.   Diesel engine repair shops in Suffolk County including Mercedes & BMW repair shops in Suffolk County NY will repair diesel cars, but may also repair diesel trucks and buses, bulldozers, tractors and other large vehicles.

Engine - The device within cars and trucks that burns fuel to produce mechanical power. It converts heat energy into mechanical energy.

Engine Overhaul - To perform engine repairs on an auto that are more than simple repairs but not as extensive as an engine rebuild.

Engine Rebuild - To perform an extensive engine repair including machining, reboring, and honing to factory-stock specifications. This is a much more extensive process than an engine overhaul.

Flooding the Engine - When too much gasoline is metered into an engine for combustion.

Front Suspension - The system that supports the weight of the front of the vehicle. Most cars have an independent front suspension.

Front-Wheel Drive - A drive system that transmits power from the engine through the front wheels. The rear wheels do not power the vehicle.

Gasoline Engine - An engine that runs on gasoline, a liquid blend of hydrocarbons used as automotive fuel and processed from crude oil.

German Car Repair Shops - German auto repair shops in Suffolk County NY are those that specialize in repairs of German cars such that they have special expertise in repairs for BMW, Mercedes Benz, Audi, Porsche, BMW Mini and others.  Being an expert in German car repair often means expertise in diesel car repair services, as well as the greater precision that is often required of German car brands known for being high performance cars.  Since the best German auto repair usually means greater experience or even foreign factory training, hourly labor rates for German auto repair are understandably often a little higher than for domestic car repairs. Since parts usually come from Germany, often made with greater precision, part costs can be a little higher too.

Hot Rod Repair Shops - Car repair shops that specialize in hot rod repair in Suffolk County NY are servicing typically American cars with big engines modified for high speed. These are often older models like Ford, Mercury, Chevy models from the 1920's to 1960's. These can include heavily modified hot rod models like the Ford Model T, Ford Model A, Ford Coupe, Chevy Master Deluxe, Hudson Hornet but also more modern and foreign makes like Volkswagen Beetles or Fiat. Hot rod repair shops in Suffolk County are familiar with highly modified, large, high performance engines. 

Italian Auto Repair Shops - These are Italian car repair services Suffolk County NY that specialize in Italian cars like Ferrari, Alfa Romeo, Lamborghini, Maserati, Lancia, Fiat, Bugatti, DeTomaso, and others. 

Muscle Cars / Muscle Car Repair Shops - American made rear wheel drive cars of the late 1960's to mid 1970's that were 'small' cars (compared to their engines) which came with large powerful V8 engines and sold as everyday cars for regular street use. Common examples still being serviced by muscle car specialists in Suffolk County are the Plymouth Road Runner, Pontiac GTO, Chevy Chevelle, Dodge Charger, Ford Gran Torino, Oldsmobile 442, Mercury Montego, AMC AMX, Plymouth GTX, AMC Rebel, Chevy Nova, Chevy Malibu, Dodge Demon, Ford Cobra, Plymouth Duster, Oldsmobile Cutlass.  These muscle cars were mass-marketed, but the automakers understood that they would attract customers interested in what was essentially a turn-key racing machine. Although sales were modest, they were considered prestige cars for the automakers.  Muscle car repair shops in Suffolk County NY will be very familiar repairing & restoring the Hemi engines and other large V8 engines found in American muscle cars. A sub-set of the muscle cars are known as "pony cars" and include smaller-sized large-engine cars like the Ford Mustang, Chevy Camaro and Plymouth Barracuda.  There are muscle car repair experts in Suffolk County NY who specialize in Ford Mustang repair, and repair of other pony cars.

Radiator - A heat exchanger that removes heat from the cooling system coolant, containing a vertical-finned or horizontal-finned tubing section connected between two tanks.

Rear-Wheel Drive - Autos powered by the engine through the rear wheels

Turbo Charger Repair (Turbocharger Repair) - A turbochargers purpose is to boost horsepower. A turbo charger should last as long as the engine but it's possible for debris to get into the turbine or compressor. Turbo charger repairs may also be needed if the lubricant is dirty or too low, or if the exhaust gas temperatures from the injection system are too high.  There are some turbocharger repair shops and turbo charger repair experts in Suffolk County who can perform a turbo charger inspection. If turbo charger repair services in Suffolk County NY cannot repair the turbo, then they can install a new or refurbished turbocharger. While you might attempt turbocharger repairs yourself, you're best off finding an expert in turbo charger repair in Suffolk County NY.

Winding the Engine - Running the engine at top RPM (Revolutions Per Minute).

Resources About Auto Repair in Suffolk County NY

Licensing & Trade Associations Related to Car Repair in Suffolk County NY

AAA www.aaa.com
AAA New Jersey www.midatlantic.aaa.com
AAAM Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine www.carcrash.org
AAIA Automotive Aftermarket Industry Association www.aftermarket.org
AASP Alliance Of Automotive Service Providers www.autoserviceproviders.com
AASP NJ Alliance of Automotive Service Providers of New Jersey www.aaspnj.org
ACA Automotive Composites Alliance www.autocomposites.org
ADS Association of Diesel Specialists www.diesel.org
AERA Engine Builders Association www.aera.org
AIAG Automotive Industry Action Group www.aiag.org
ASA Automotive Service Association www.asashop.org
ASE National Institute for Automotive Service Excellence www.asecert.org
BBB The Better Business Bureau www.bbb.com
NARSA National Automotive Radiator Service Association www.narsa.org
NATEF National Automotive Technicians Education Foundation www.natef.org
SAE Society of Automotive Engineers automobile.sae.org
SEMA Specialty Equipment Market Association www.sema.org

Magazines/Media Related to Auto Repair in Suffolk County NY

Autofan
Automotive News
Automotive Rebuilder
Auto Week
Import Car
Car and Driver
Detroit News
Hemmings Motornews
Motor Age
Motor Trend
Recyclers World
Road & Track
Sport Compact Car
Street Rodder
Super Chevy
Today's SUV
Truckin'
Turbo And High Performance Magazine
Turbo And High Tech Performance
4wd Magazine
US Auto News
Underhood Service
VW Trends

The Prime Buyer's Report provides information for the TOP 10 Auto Repair in Suffolk County NY within the following zip codes:

The Prime Buyer's Report provides information for the TOP 10 Car Repair in Suffolk County NY within the following cities:

Bay Shore, Brentwood, Centereach, Central Islip, Commack, Copiague, Coram, Deer Park, Dix Hills, East Islip, East Northport, East Patchogue, Farmingville, Hauppauge, Holbrook, Holtsville, Huntington, Huntington Station, Islip, Kings Park, Lake Ronkonkoma, Lindenhurst, Mastic, Medford, Melville, North Amityville, North Babylon, North Bay Shore, Ronkonkoma, Sayville, Selden, Setauket-East Setauket, Shirley, Smithtown, West Babylon, West Islip, East Hampton, Riverhead and Southold